Identifying Nerve-Related Back Pain vs. Muscular Pain

Back pain is one of the most common reasons people seek medical care, but not all back pain is the same. Understanding whether your discomfort stems from nerve-related back pain or muscle-related back pain is crucial for finding the right treatment and getting lasting relief.
While both conditions can significantly impact your daily life, they’re actually quite different in terms of their underlying causes, symptoms, and recovery approaches. Today, the team at Elliott Physical Therapy will break it down for you so you can better understand your pain–and get the care you need.
Nerve-Related Vs. Muscular Back Pain: What You Need to Know
All About Nerve-Related Back Pain
As its name suggests, nerve-related back pain occurs when something goes wrong with one of your nerves, such as becoming compressed, irritated, or inflamed.
Causes of Nerve-Related Back Pain
- Bulging or herniated discs that compress nearby nerves
- A narrowing of the spinal canal (spinal stenosis) that causes the nerves to become pinched
- Damage to structures surrounding the spine
Signs Your Back Pain is Nerve-Related
- Sharp, shooting, or radiating pain that travels into the arms or legs
- Tingling, burning sensations, or numbness
- Weakness in certain muscle groups
- Pain that worsens with specific movements or positions
All About Muscular Back Pain
Muscular back refers stems from damage to the soft tissues in your back, including the muscles themselves, the ligaments (which connect the vertebrae in the spine), and tendons (which attach back muscles to bone).
Causes of Muscular Back Pain
- Overuse damage from repetitive movements
- Sudden strain from twisting or lifting heavy objects improperly
- Body imbalances and/or a sedentary lifestyle, which weakens the tissues and makes you more susceptible to injury.
Signs Your Back Pain is Muscle-Related
- Dull, achy, or throbbing discomfort localized to one area
- Muscle tightness or spasms
- Pain that improves with rest or gentle movement
- Minimal or no radiating pain
Exploring How Physical Therapy Adapts to Each Condition
At Elliott PT, we understand that nerve-related back pain and muscular pain develop for different reasons and thus require different treatment options. That’s why we stress a personalized approach to physical therapy.
Below, we share two example stories (names have been changed) to help you understand the different treatment approaches for different types of back pain.
Overcoming Nerve-Related Back Pain with Elizabeth
Elizabeth came to see us when she began experiencing sharp, shooting pain through her lower back and leg. We determined she had suffered a herniated disc.
We kicked her treatment off with techniques to help reduce nerve irritation, including controlled exercises designed to take pressure off the affected nerve, targeted manual therapy and mobilization of her nerves, . As her pain improved, we introduced more stability and mobility training to support her spine and prevent flare-ups.
Over several weeks, Elizabeth regained her ability to stand and walk for long periods without discomfort, enabling her to return to teaching with renewed confidence.
Recovering from Muscular Back Pain with David
David was a landscaper who injured his back while lifting heavy bags of mulch, resulting in muscular pain.
His therapy focused on soft tissue techniques to ease muscle spasms and reduce inflammation. Once his pain subsided, we transitioned him to a strengthening program that rebuilt his core and back muscle endurance. This progressive approach not only resolved his immediate pain but also equipped him with the strength needed to safely handle the physical demands of his job.
Take the Next Step Toward Relief
Getting the right diagnosis and treatment plan is key, whether you’re dealing with nerve-related or muscular back pain. Either way, our team of physical therapists will create personalized care plans to help you recover safely and effectively.
Don’t wait to feel better. Contact Elliott PT today to schedule an appointment and take the first step toward lasting relief.
